— my · the missing dish

a small mystery of the dinner-service · no. iv of ten
first noted · 1944, on the death of the service's owner
investigators · the cook; one inventory clerk
current theory · that the dish was never made, and is still expected

the missing dish

the blue dinner-set is a service for twelve, ordered from a small pottery in 1899 and delivered the following spring. it consists, by manifest, of twelve dinner plates, twelve soup plates, twelve side plates, twelve teacups, twelve saucers, a tureen, two platters, a sauce-boat, and four small sweet-dishes. it has been in continuous use, with care, for over a century. it is now — and has been for as long as anyone has counted — one dish short. the missing dish is a side plate.

what is known: no fragment has been found. the pantry has been cleared out three times. the pottery, in 1947, was approached for a replacement; the owner replied with a polite letter explaining that their records showed eleven side plates only on the original order, which is contradicted by the keeper's manifest and by the receipt in the keeper's diary. the dish does not exist in the photograph of the dinner held to celebrate the service's first laying. the dish does not exist in the painting of the same dinner. the dish does not exist in anyone's memory.

three theories. the cook holds that the dish was broken on its first night and that the breaking was quietly absorbed into the household's silence, the way certain other things are absorbed; she does not name them. the inventory clerk holds, simply, that the manifest is wrong — that the pottery's letter is correct, that there were always eleven, that the keeper's diary is in error. the keeper holds that the dish is still in transit, and that to ask for a replacement would be to fail in patience.

field note · l. m. the keeper laid the table this evening for eleven, although twelve were expected. when asked, she said she had laid it for the people present. the place to the left of the visitor was set with a folded napkin and no plate.
small mysteries · atlas · return