charcoal · october · sketchbook p. 14
the same chair from the kitchen, drawn three times on a single afternoon and never twice the same. front, then three-quarter, then a foreshortened view from a stepladder. it is the chair from corvin's painting, repainted out of stubbornness — not to copy him but to disagree.
the charcoal was too soft for the line and kept smudging into the rail of the back. study (i) is the most honest. study (ii) the proudest, and therefore wrong. study (iii) was abandoned at the legs: the chair refused to be seen from above, the way a face refuses to be photographed at the wrong angle.
what is wrong is the seat. in all three drawings the seat is too shallow, as though no one were meant to sit there. corvin had this problem too. so perhaps it is the chair's fault, not the hand's.
field-note · margin think of it as three attempts at the same sentence. only the first is true. the rest are translations.